About Me

My photo

I completed my medical school and background EM training from India (Christian Medical College, Vellore and Apollo Hospitals, Hyderabad) where I worked for 4 years. Following this, I devoted (with all my heart) about 1.5 years to do US Medical Licensing Exams. My stint towards an EM Residency in States did not work but it took me to places and it has been quite a journey. I then relocated to London, England to work as a Registrar (Non-Trainee) in A&E. This gave me an opportunity to better understand NHS, EM training pathways and more importantly the EM Mindsets in the United Kingdom. 

Currently, I am pursuing Higher Specialist Training in Emergency Medicine at South East Scotland Deanery where I have the honour and privilege of training under some of the most innovative brains in the field of Emergency Medicine. Over the past few years, I have realised that LEARNING and UNLEARNING (which can be challenging!) is equally important to deliver cutting edge care to our patients.And through this blog, I aspire to disseminate knowledge, assist trainees with exams and stay up to date with contemporary EM literature. I have always been an avid FOAMed supporter because FOAMed has always played an indispensable role during my training. 


Lakshay Chanana
ST4 EM Trainee 
Edinburgh, Scotland
drlakshayem@gmail.com

Monday, February 22, 2016

Patients, Physicians and Google - What are we up to?

In this era of technology, all of us have dealt with patients who first "google" their symptoms, try and figure out what is possibly happening with them, reach a self diagnosis and try some remedies to see if their symptoms get better. And if things don't settle down, then they visit a physician. From whatever I have observed so far, most physicians tend to get upset with these patients (some physicians call them semi-literate patients or an e-patient) but only a handful of them actually try and talk to them, dig deep and understand their concerns, do shared decision making and reach a treatment plan that is acceptable to both, the physician as well as the patient. 
It is not uncommon to come across this demanding subgroup of patients in the ED but in the outpatient setting where there are no time constraints, every other patient is an e-patient. Let us understand why do patients do this:


Why ask google when physicians are available? 

In a physician - patient relationship, historically the physicians have dominated the conversation (ideally it should be the other way around) and patients have always been submissive. But things are changing and many find it hard to accept when a patient questions on a diagnosis or treatment plan. Also in modern day scenario, I think the key issue that we are dealing with is lack of trust on physicians . If we look back at the last decade, the way media and television has projected physicians, things have really gone away too far and it has changed a lot. Now, patients do not see physicians as someone they can readily rely on, so they want some baseline information to start with. And when they visit a doctor, their chief concern is that they do not want to be mislead with unwanted investigations and sometimes unnecessary medications. What remains the best way to get unbiased help is the always available "GOOGLE". 

And this may not be the only reason for googling symptoms, people have also become more aware and they want to know what is happening with them and much more about the medications, side effects. Fortunately (for some physicians), this wave of technology has spread only to the metropolitans and a majority of patients in India are still clingy and depend completely on doctors to make decisions for them.






How do physicians react when they deal with an e-patient?

All of us would agree on this that doctors have big egos and as physicians do get offended thinking that they are confusing our medical degree with google or we might think that 

How can he come with a self-diagnosis? 
Then why the hell did I go to medical school?

Due to this passive aggression, poor rapport and cold relationship these patients get shunted among various specialists (which is bad medicine) consuming time and wasting resources.

We as health care providers, need to understand that medicine is much more than just making the correct diagnosis and treatment. Empathising and emotional support to a patient often can do wonders to patient's compliance and symptom relief. Social media, technology and google cannot give them the healing touch, but you can. It just needs some patience and a few extra minutes.


What can we possibly do about e-patients?

Short answer: Shed your ego and do shared decision making

If a patient is enlisting his/her symptoms and also what they read about it on internet, be upfront and ask them what do they think is happening with them and be willing to listen to their self-diagnosis (which might be the correct diagnosis!). Listen to them carefully without the prejudice that they are wrong. Ask them where did they read about it and what do you think about what they have read. Also give them some more reliable resources to refer to a t then end of your consultation.

Most of them don't want to offend you and neither they are testing your knowledge but they are just concerned about their health and want to participate in understanding their illness, more importantly they want to have a feeling of security and reassurance that they are not being mislead. Unfortunately this is what we have come down to. Our job is still to help them out, take a few minutes and do shared decision making. These e-patients are only going to increase in future, so rather than creating being insecure and making a hue and cry about this, we need to accept this and be amazed if they are not googling their symptoms!

Googling symptoms is absolutely normal.


And guess what do physicians do when they want information on something?
Google


What if you have no idea about what they are talking about?

If you have no clue about a treatment that they are referring to, before you tell them that it makes no sense. Check on that and don't be surprised if they tell you something about medicine that you don't already know. (Something like non-surgical treatment for appendicitis). Medicine is making advancements everyday and it is hard to stay up to date. So hold on, tell them that you have not heard of something like this but you will find out more on this and revert back. Many times, patients with chronic diseases know more about their disease and treatment than an emergency physician!

I think sooner or later we are going to have a computer that can give a reliable list of differentials. We already have systems in place that alert us about various drug reactions, doses etc. then why not a list of possible differentials. But again, medicine is not about only the diagnosis and treatment. A physician has much more to offer..


Bottom Line:
  • Shed your egos and just listen to them.
  • Look at e-patients as a possible help. Most of them are just concerned and want to make sure they are on the right track. 
  • Set the right rapport and build that trust to drive things smooth. 

3 comments: